What Is A Purpose-Driven Life to Americans?
- Get link
- Other Apps
May 17, 2005
(Ventura, CA) – Religious books have become a publishing phenomenon in the past decade, and no religious book (other than the Bible) has generated more attention – or sales – than Rick Warren’s bestseller, The Purpose-Driven Life. More than 20 million copies of the book have been sold, and millions of people have been exposed to Purpose-Driven church programs, classes and resources. After all the reading, teaching, and conversation on the topic, exactly what do Americans perceive their purpose in life to be?
That was the question posed to a random national sample of 1003 adults surveyed by The Barna Group. One particular response was provided by nearly half of the population, and only two other options were mentioned by at least one out of every ten people.
Read the rest of the article here.
My response:
First, Barna’s group should do a little more research. “Pilgrim’s Progress” has been the most read book in the world after the Bible since 1678.
Second, the article should have been titled, “The American-Driven Life.” One could not help but notice in reading the above-mentioned article that of all the responses given by those polled, not a single one of Warren’s suggested “purposes” are mentioned by Americans. One wonders how the poll was constructed based on the answers . . . were Warren’s “purposes” even on the list?
The responses tell me that people are still pursuing the “American Dream”, to be healthy, wealthy, have a family, to live in peace and occasionally do the American thing: go to church. Assuming the poll actually included any one of Warren’s “purposes”, the responses also tell me that of those polled, few must have read the book or actually paid any attention to what it said. This is obvious because the responses given in the poll would logically not have been any different if they were asked what their perceived purpose would be if every child had a little red wagon.
What I saw in the poll was both a relief and a two distresses.
The relief came when I deduced that not many of those polled (assumingly) remember (by now) anything about reading Rick Warren or their church having followed the 40 days of Purpose. Case in point: raise your hand if you remember David and Karen Mains and their 40 Day Adventures from the 1980’s? Of course I am arguing from silence.
My distress is based on a confusion of terminology:
The dictionary defines “priority” thusly:
1. a. (1) : the quality or state of being prior; (2) : precedence in date or position of publication
1. b. (1) : superiority in rank, position, or privilege; (2) : legal precedence in exercise of rights over the same subject matter
2 : a preferential rating; especially : one that allocates rights to goods and services usually in limited supply; “that project has top priority.”
3 : something given or meriting attention before competing alternatives
That which has “priority” is the same which comes first, is that which precedes all others in time, order and importance as the highest or most prominent part, before and in preference of something else, etc.
The same dictionary also renders “foremost” as a noun and an adverb:
(noun)
1 : first in a series or progression
2 : of first rank or position : PREEMINENT
(adverb)
1 : in the first place
2 : most importantly “first and foremost”
The poll results say “Family first, faith foremost.” How can that be? Which is it? There are two options: 1) the poll writers and reporters need to open the dictionary; and/or 2) Americans don’t know what is first in their lives. Is it "faith" or "family"?
Bottom line: those polled reveal they don’t know what their purpose is! There is no such thing as “priorities.” By definition, there can be no more than one priority in anyone’s life!
The Second distress: no hearts where changed by Rick Warren’s ministry because people are still thinking about themselves and what they want for their own happiness. Where is the Christ? Where are the changed lives of those who have forsaken everything for the cross? Where is the hope of the resurrection and the expectation of the coming of the LORD?
I would say that the polls reveal the Purpose Driven life did'nt work--at least to those polls. The people obviously did not learn anything. Just another proof that man's way cannot replace God's ways.
Isaiah chapter 1.
(Ventura, CA) – Religious books have become a publishing phenomenon in the past decade, and no religious book (other than the Bible) has generated more attention – or sales – than Rick Warren’s bestseller, The Purpose-Driven Life. More than 20 million copies of the book have been sold, and millions of people have been exposed to Purpose-Driven church programs, classes and resources. After all the reading, teaching, and conversation on the topic, exactly what do Americans perceive their purpose in life to be?
That was the question posed to a random national sample of 1003 adults surveyed by The Barna Group. One particular response was provided by nearly half of the population, and only two other options were mentioned by at least one out of every ten people.
Read the rest of the article here.
My response:
First, Barna’s group should do a little more research. “Pilgrim’s Progress” has been the most read book in the world after the Bible since 1678.
Second, the article should have been titled, “The American-Driven Life.” One could not help but notice in reading the above-mentioned article that of all the responses given by those polled, not a single one of Warren’s suggested “purposes” are mentioned by Americans. One wonders how the poll was constructed based on the answers . . . were Warren’s “purposes” even on the list?
The responses tell me that people are still pursuing the “American Dream”, to be healthy, wealthy, have a family, to live in peace and occasionally do the American thing: go to church. Assuming the poll actually included any one of Warren’s “purposes”, the responses also tell me that of those polled, few must have read the book or actually paid any attention to what it said. This is obvious because the responses given in the poll would logically not have been any different if they were asked what their perceived purpose would be if every child had a little red wagon.
What I saw in the poll was both a relief and a two distresses.
The relief came when I deduced that not many of those polled (assumingly) remember (by now) anything about reading Rick Warren or their church having followed the 40 days of Purpose. Case in point: raise your hand if you remember David and Karen Mains and their 40 Day Adventures from the 1980’s? Of course I am arguing from silence.
My distress is based on a confusion of terminology:
The dictionary defines “priority” thusly:
1. a. (1) : the quality or state of being prior; (2) : precedence in date or position of publication
1. b. (1) : superiority in rank, position, or privilege; (2) : legal precedence in exercise of rights over the same subject matter
2 : a preferential rating; especially : one that allocates rights to goods and services usually in limited supply; “that project has top priority.”
3 : something given or meriting attention before competing alternatives
That which has “priority” is the same which comes first, is that which precedes all others in time, order and importance as the highest or most prominent part, before and in preference of something else, etc.
The same dictionary also renders “foremost” as a noun and an adverb:
(noun)
1 : first in a series or progression
2 : of first rank or position : PREEMINENT
(adverb)
1 : in the first place
2 : most importantly “first and foremost”
The poll results say “Family first, faith foremost.” How can that be? Which is it? There are two options: 1) the poll writers and reporters need to open the dictionary; and/or 2) Americans don’t know what is first in their lives. Is it "faith" or "family"?
Bottom line: those polled reveal they don’t know what their purpose is! There is no such thing as “priorities.” By definition, there can be no more than one priority in anyone’s life!
The Second distress: no hearts where changed by Rick Warren’s ministry because people are still thinking about themselves and what they want for their own happiness. Where is the Christ? Where are the changed lives of those who have forsaken everything for the cross? Where is the hope of the resurrection and the expectation of the coming of the LORD?
I would say that the polls reveal the Purpose Driven life did'nt work--at least to those polls. The people obviously did not learn anything. Just another proof that man's way cannot replace God's ways.
Isaiah chapter 1.
- Get link
- Other Apps
Popular posts from this blog
“Men and women who saw God in the Bible: Why did they not all die?”
July 2004 I went to Kenya, Africa to speak in two Pastor’s Conferences on the subject of Man, Sin and Salvation. At the end of each day I left just over an hour for questions (half the time were questions touching the subject of my lectures, and the other half for “open questions”; that is, people could ask anything). For the next few weeks, I will be sharing the questions that were asked of me, and my answers—and believe me when I say these people really know how to think! Question from Kenya #1: “Men and women who saw God in the Bible: Why did they not all die?” [“ But He said, ‘You cannot see My face, for no man can see Me and live! ’” (Exodus 33:20) was the basis of the student’s question]. Answer: First, consider those who did see God—how did they respond when they saw Him? They were instantly aware of their sinfulness, and God’s holiness and righteousness (to name a few. And notice also that each responded in an attitude of worship, bowing down): Abraham built altars, wors
A Sonnet
“My God, where is that ancient heat towards thee, Wherewith whole shoals of martyrs once did burn, Besides their other flames? Doth poetry Wear Venus' livery? only serve her turn? Why are not sonnets made of thee? and lays Upon thine altar burnt? Cannot thy love Heighten a spirit to sound out thy praise As well as any she? Cannot thy Dove Outstrip their Cupid easily in flight? Or, since thy ways are deep, and still the fame, Will not a verse run smooth that bears thy name! Why doth that fire, which by thy power and might Each breast does feel, no braver fuel choose Than that, which one day, worms may chance refuse. Sure Lord, there is enough in thee to dry Oceans of ink; for, as the Deluge did Cover the earth, so doth thy Majesty: Each cloud distills thy praise, and doth forbid Poets to turn it to another use. Roses and lilies speak thee; and to make A pair of cheeks of them, is thy abuse Why should I women's eyes for crystal take? Such poor invention burns in their low mind Wh
Welcome, May!
The past few weeks have been stressful. Training new employees, dealing with difficult customers, not sleeping well, not exercising (I’ve gained 20 pounds in the last two years), getting through family drama (two life-threatening events in the same day, 2000 miles apart: my dad’s heart attack in NM and a 9 year grandchild starting the rest of his life with Type 1 Diabetes) . . . My CrossFit lifestyle withered into oblivion when I lost my job at the University in 2020, as Covid got going. Deep depression brought me to a standstill as I took a few months to try to reset. Since then, my physical status has been on steady decline. Now my daily schedule looks something like this: Work 3-11 pm (on a good day), Go to bed at 4 am, get up between 10:30 am and noon, get booted up and go back to work. If I get one day off a week I’m fortunate. At least I don’t have to work all night for now. That was the worst. So I haven’t had time or energy to do much, even read, much less write. And since my